At Issue: Oklahoma media outlet Oklahoma Watch is amplifying allegations made by lawyers suing State Farm while limiting readers' access to State Farm's perspective. The reports lean heavily on high-volume plaintiff attorneys, contractors, and public adjusters as “experts,” and treat political commentary as claims-handling expertise, while downplaying the fact that these claims are still being litigated. These matters involve pending litigation. State Farm is limited in what it can discuss publicly and has provided written responses rather than participating in live interviews. Oklahoma Watch has declined to publish those responses. However, the outlet has relied on email-sourced comments in other reporting, creating an inconsistent standard that leaves readers with an incomplete picture of the matter.
Why It Matters: Oklahomans deserve reporting that clearly separates allegations from proven facts and includes relevant context from all sides. When coverage becomes a steady drumbeat of one perspective, it fuels distrust and confusion - at a time when people need reliable protection, and Oklahoma needs a strong, solvent insurance market that can pay claims after the next storm.
For The Record:
- We responded consistently and in writing. State Farm regularly provided clear, fact-based written responses and offered context. Oklahoma Watch chose not to include those responses, stating it does not publish prepared statements and prefers live, back-and-forth interviews.
- That approach creates a predictable imbalance. When only certain voices are repeatedly platformed, especially those positioned as “claims experts” who have financial incentives (some attorneys, contractors, and public adjusters) or political incentives (public officials) - readers are steered toward a conclusion before the facts are fully presented.
- These matters involve pending litigation. We can’t comment publicly on the specifics of any individual case, even if someone else involved chooses to speak with the media. Court rules and state and federal privacy laws require all parties to handle information responsibly, and we won’t litigate individual claims in the press.
- We pay claims in Oklahoma. Over the past two years, State Farm has paid more than $1 billion to Oklahoma customers for wind and hail damage. Oklahoma experiences some of the highest wind and hail losses in the country. If we owe it, we pay it.
- The real problem requires real solutions. Rising costs are driven by inflation and more weather-related losses. Progress means stronger home and community resilience measures, not sensational narratives.
- We are here, we are local, and we care. More than 300 local State Farm agents, their teams, and State Farm employees serve millions of customers across Oklahoma, and we remain committed to working with the Oklahoma Department of Insurance to benefit Oklahoma customers.
We take every claim seriously, we review concerns carefully, and we work to pay all benefits a customer is entitled to under the policy. If a customer has questions about their claim, we encourage them to contact their State Farm agent or claim representative so we can review their individual situation and help answer their questions.